10 Must-Try Autumn Pie Recipes for Thanksgiving

Introduction

Thanksgiving signals the heart of autumn when comfort and tradition shine, and few desserts bring families together quite like pie. These 10 must-try autumn pie recipes are packed with seasonal flavors, from classic spiced pumpkin to innovative apple-cranberry combinations. Whether you’re hosting a big gathering or an intimate meal, these crowd-pleasing pies add warmth and a sense of celebration to any Thanksgiving table.

Why These Autumn Pies Stand Out

Each recipe on this list showcases the vibrant flavors of the season—think cinnamon-kissed apples, toasted pecans, and silky sweet potatoes—all elegantly encased in flaky, golden crusts. By blending time-honored favorites with inventive twists, this collection ensures there’s a perfect pie for every palate, making dessert the highlight of your holiday feast.

Featured Autumn Pie Recipes

1. **Classic Pumpkin Pie** – Creamy, spiced filling in a buttery crust
2. **Maple Pecan Pie** – Lusciously sweet with maple syrup and toasted pecans
3. **Apple-Cranberry Pie** – Tart cranberries balance sweet apples in this vibrant, jewel-toned pie
4. **Sweet Potato Pie** – Silky-smooth with hints of vanilla and warming spices
5. **Salted Caramel Apple Pie** – Gooey caramel mingles with cinnamon-spiced apples
6. **Chocolate-Bourbon Pecan Pie** – Decadent chocolate and a splash of bourbon elevate this Southern classic
7. **Brown Butter Pear Pie** – Nutty brown butter brings richness to tender pears
8. **Chai-Spiced Pumpkin Pie** – Traditional pumpkin enhanced with exotic chai spices
9. **Rustic Cranberry Galette** – Freeform and fuss-free, bursting with tangy cranberries
10. **Pear and Ginger Pie** – Fragrant ginger adds warmth to juicy, ripe pears

Essential Ingredients for Perfect Autumn Pies

– Classic pie crusts (homemade or store-bought)
– Pumpkin puree
– Sweet potatoes
– Fresh apples and pears
– Fresh or frozen cranberries
– Pecans
– Eggs
– Heavy cream or evaporated milk
– Butter (unsalted, for crusts and fillings)
– Brown and granulated sugar
– Maple syrup
– Ground cinnamon and nutmeg
– Ginger (fresh or ground)
– Bourbon or vanilla extract
– Chocolate chips (for chocolate pecan pie)
– Salt and baking essentials

💡Meal Planning Tip: Save this pie collection using CookifyAI to instantly generate an organized, shareable shopping list sorted by grocery aisle—perfect for prepping Thanksgiving desserts without the stress of forgotten ingredients.

Pie-Making Instructions Overview

Each pie recipe follows a classic technique for success:

1. Prepare your crust. In most cases, chill your dough before rolling and fitting it into your pie pan, docking the bottom gently with a fork.
2. Mix your filling. For fruit pies, toss sliced fruit with sugar, spices, and thickeners like flour or cornstarch. For custard pies, whisk filling ingredients until smooth.
3. Assemble and bake. Pour the filling into the crust; top with lattice or crumb, if needed. Bake until set and golden, following individual recipe instructions for times and temperatures.
4. Cool and serve. Allow pies to cool for cleaner slices. Serve with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for extra decadence!

Serving Suggestions

Impress your guests by presenting a stunning pie display, garnished with sugared cranberries, toasted nuts, or a drizzle of caramel sauce. Offer a variety so everyone can sample a slice (or two) of their favorites. These pies pair beautifully with freshly brewed coffee or spiced cider on a chilly November evening.

Nutritional Information and Serving Size

Most pies on this list serve 8–10 people, depending on slice size. Classic autumn pies typically contain 250–400 calories per serving, mostly from wholesome ingredients like fruit, eggs, nuts, and seasonal spices—ideal for guilt-free indulgence during the holidays!

Autumn Pie Recipes Recap

With these 10 must-try autumn pie recipes, you’ll delight every guest at your Thanksgiving table. Each option celebrates the richness of the season with inviting aromas, colorful fillings, and memorable flavor combinations.

💡Meal Planning Tip: Save these recipes to CookifyAI and generate a ready-to-shop list, sorted by store section for maximum efficiency. Share your list with family so everyone can pitch in—no ingredient left behind!

Weekly Meal Planning

Sweeten your holiday week by prepping these pies in advance. Schedule these recipes in CookifyAI to organize when each pie gets baked and served, and see a complete shopping list that pulls from all your planned holiday meals.

Planning Benefits:

– Calculates total quantities if making multiple pies (no running out of eggs!)
– Suggests make-ahead options and baking timelines for stress-free prep
– Prevents duplicate purchases and reduces holiday shopping chaos
– Makes Thanksgiving meal planning as easy as pie

Pro tip: Planning both savory dishes and desserts? Add all your recipes to consolidate the complete list—saving time, money, and hassle.

Cook and Prep Times

Prep Time: 25–40 minutes per pie
Bake Time: 45–60 minutes per pie
Total Time: 90 minutes (average for mixing, baking, and cooling)

Prepare, plan, and savor the sweetest part of Thanksgiving with these 10 unmissable autumn pies!